Assimilation is the key. People from different societies act differently. Idiotic migration policies and the ignorant expectation that they are "just like us". If they were just like us their countries would be just like West.
Visiting France, it's immediately clear it was only the French who believed in this notion of assimilation. Many immigrants have no interest whatsover in French culture.
Thanks for this excellent summary of the present crisis and historic analysis. The list of examples of crime and violence brought by immigration is simply terrifying.
The French indeed did it to themselves. The question is -- can France be saved? The only way out of it, it seems, would be to stop the immigration from Muslim countries, review the current immigrants and recently naturalized citizens and deport/denaturalize anyone who has any record of criminal or antisocial behavior. Leave only those who have shown good progress towards assimilation. It's a lot of work -- but you cannot leave these people in the country. And of course the laws must be strictly enforced. Why did not police shot at these raging violent lunatics and instead allowed them to run wild for days?
The divided communities of Ulster had a mass immigration event throughout the 17th century and have been physically fighting over it as recently as 1999. That’s almost 400 years from the first settlement to the most recent fighting. It’s an awfully long time.
These are both Northern European Christian communities but their differences were enough to cause significant violence for many lifetimes.
The violence in Ulster is almost twice as old as the USA’s status as a country.
So a failure of assimilation is not an “oops I need to fix that” kind of problem, it has the potential to be a “this land will now be contested for hundreds of years, sometimes violently” problem. These things tend to have a delayed consequence aspect and we see this in places like Sweden where 2nd and 3rd generation immigrants from non-European countries commit crimes at higher rates than the first generation immigrants. In other words this is whatever the opposite of assimilation is.
Islam has a long-standing model for winning such contests over hundreds of years.
Threaten (and periodically enact) extreme violence but offer peaceful servitude if you submit and don’t fight back.
In this sense, it is correct to call it a religion of peace. It is peace through submission to the will of Allah. Submission is the essence of the theology and it is antithetical to European enlightenment ideas like “liberté, égalité, fraternité” or its Anglo liberal versions.
There are two levels of submission, firstly temporal, then spiritual: level 1, initially pay the Jizya but remain free to practice your religions and customs. Level 2, join the Umma.
The Jizya does not exist in Europe today, but transfer payments from Europeans to Muslim newcomers will increasingly function as a de facto Jizya and calls for this in the form of productivity-destroying transfer payments will grow along with the size of Muslim enclaves that are increasingly dominated by Islamists. In sufficient concentrations, moderate Muslims will submit (as they have always done) to the Islamists among them. The UAE has zero tolerance for Islamism which is why it has much less of problem with this than France, UK and Germany. In Europe, the Islamists are deeply entrenched and can increasingly wield Muslim communities as a weapon of political domination against their host states.
It is already happening and will continue to happen. In order to ensure it keeps happening, the Islamists will want to import more and more Muslims, faster and faster, into European lands.
This is extremely similar to what happened in Ulster. Most Catholics in Ulster have never been members of the IRA, but the IRA (and its various factions) have wielded extraordinary political power via (at most) a few thousand committed cadres.
The only solution is to root out Islamism from Muslim communities, but it is already too late to do this.
This is the very definition of a slow-moving train wreck.
10, 20 years from now people will ask “how could we not have seen this coming” and the truth will be that we could, but our leaders found it expedient to ignore it all and hope for the best.
France didn't "lose" the ability to assimilate Muslims. That ability simply never existed --because Muslims are the committed enemy of the West.
They didn't come to France to contribute. They came to France to kill, loot, and take control. This was always the plan and it was always obvious. Only a leftist could overlook such a fundamental truth.
Whether this is true on a larger scale is demonstrated by statistical data and I don’t see the evidence, and whether it’s true on the individual level is contradicted by examples such as the ones I offered in the article. The threat is real, I agree, and the ideology is as you say, but most people have multiple interests and are defined by various formative influences.
If France were a person, it would be someone with a severe narcissistic disorder—constantly lecturing others while ignoring its own faults and shortcomings, and hypocritically disregarding its own procalimed ideals whenever it suits the situation.
These protests—or rather, riots, however the media might choose to spin the narrative—are downplayed in Europe as merely part of "French culture." While that may be true to some extent, it seems that with each passing year, the French become increasingly blinded by this myth of theirs; as long as they can enjoy a glass of wine and a cigarette on a café terrace, they simply do not care.
France is burning and the Western press acts like it’s a damn optical illusion. Streets on fire, social order cracking, but the media tiptoes around it, terrified of admitting their own failures. Yet when Iran sneezes, they scream apocalypse for weeks. That’s the filthy hypocrisy: silence when chaos erupts at home, hysteria when it’s abroad. Their narrative machine is exposed — selective outrage, selective truth, selective morality — all of it rotten, all of it collapsing.
Fantastic piece , and I do have to wonder if you reach a place where assimilation is no longer realistically an option. The question is , where do you find the "grownups" who are willing and able to confront this? This appears to be far beyond "a house divided".
I grew up in the banlieues in the '70s, I've been living in the US for close to 30 years.
What I would have liked to see in this summary:
-the rise of Islamism dates from the '80s (probably started in the late '70s after the oil shocks and the Iranian revolution), with the Gulf funding madrassas, mosques etc. in France then.
-most Arabs in France (people did not call them Muslims then) were pretty secular when I grew up, up until maybe the '90s. There were exceptions of course.
-Islamic radicalism attracts mostly 2nd, 3rd and 4th generation North-Africans (and others from Muslim background) in search of identity: they resent their parents and grandparents for being sell-outs.
-I have no doubt recent immigration waves brought their share of potential Islamists, but the native born are the brunt of it (see Bataclan).
-During the Algerian war the FLN motto was "La valise ou le cercueil" (the suitcase or the coffin), their strategy was a precursor to the Second Intifada: terrorise the civilian population, especially the youth, and they will leave. Hamas fully embraced the FLN strategy. Mujahideen was a term used for Arab fighters during the war.
-the Algerian civil war spilled in France in the '90s, fueling the then FN (Front National) and igniting the identification of young Arabs with the Muslim Brotherhood.
The current riots are more cosplay than real I would think, in spite of the violence, since '68 the French regularly love to ape the French Revolution and reach another year zero.
That being said, there is a large Muslim population now in France, and you'll see that a lot more poignantly in small towns, that does not and cannot integrate French society with its liberal values: equality of the sexes, tolerance of homosexuality and other religions etc.
This will pave the way for the Rassemblement National of LePen.
A thought - how come citizens with origins from Haiti and Vietnam (both former colonies, with the first one having had to pay for its freedom over centuries, leaving it in heavy debt) seem to not be doing this? When Muslims were trying to take over public spaces for prayer, there were a lot of black people in the crowd who protested for secularism.
The problem in France right now is mainly Islam, but it's not just Islam. It's having a critical mass of Muslims, the erosion of assimilative institutions for immigrants, a collaborationist left, and a complicit media ecosystem.
Sadly this problem is also in the UK, as much as the mainstream insists on denying it and even Conservative politicians try to excuse Sharia courts here.
This is an excellent summary. I live in France and I can tell you that the situation is difficult and polarized. There is the far left which is Islamist -leftist and the far right which anti-european and frankly very scary. We have the perfect horseshoe where both extremes have a similar economic disastrous policy and pro-Russian and anti-Semitic stance. We would need a de Gaulle to bring order to this mess. The next year’s elections will be critical.
Assimilation is the key. People from different societies act differently. Idiotic migration policies and the ignorant expectation that they are "just like us". If they were just like us their countries would be just like West.
Visiting France, it's immediately clear it was only the French who believed in this notion of assimilation. Many immigrants have no interest whatsover in French culture.
Thanks for this excellent summary of the present crisis and historic analysis. The list of examples of crime and violence brought by immigration is simply terrifying.
The French indeed did it to themselves. The question is -- can France be saved? The only way out of it, it seems, would be to stop the immigration from Muslim countries, review the current immigrants and recently naturalized citizens and deport/denaturalize anyone who has any record of criminal or antisocial behavior. Leave only those who have shown good progress towards assimilation. It's a lot of work -- but you cannot leave these people in the country. And of course the laws must be strictly enforced. Why did not police shot at these raging violent lunatics and instead allowed them to run wild for days?
The Ulsterization of everything.
The divided communities of Ulster had a mass immigration event throughout the 17th century and have been physically fighting over it as recently as 1999. That’s almost 400 years from the first settlement to the most recent fighting. It’s an awfully long time.
These are both Northern European Christian communities but their differences were enough to cause significant violence for many lifetimes.
The violence in Ulster is almost twice as old as the USA’s status as a country.
So a failure of assimilation is not an “oops I need to fix that” kind of problem, it has the potential to be a “this land will now be contested for hundreds of years, sometimes violently” problem. These things tend to have a delayed consequence aspect and we see this in places like Sweden where 2nd and 3rd generation immigrants from non-European countries commit crimes at higher rates than the first generation immigrants. In other words this is whatever the opposite of assimilation is.
Islam has a long-standing model for winning such contests over hundreds of years.
Threaten (and periodically enact) extreme violence but offer peaceful servitude if you submit and don’t fight back.
In this sense, it is correct to call it a religion of peace. It is peace through submission to the will of Allah. Submission is the essence of the theology and it is antithetical to European enlightenment ideas like “liberté, égalité, fraternité” or its Anglo liberal versions.
There are two levels of submission, firstly temporal, then spiritual: level 1, initially pay the Jizya but remain free to practice your religions and customs. Level 2, join the Umma.
The Jizya does not exist in Europe today, but transfer payments from Europeans to Muslim newcomers will increasingly function as a de facto Jizya and calls for this in the form of productivity-destroying transfer payments will grow along with the size of Muslim enclaves that are increasingly dominated by Islamists. In sufficient concentrations, moderate Muslims will submit (as they have always done) to the Islamists among them. The UAE has zero tolerance for Islamism which is why it has much less of problem with this than France, UK and Germany. In Europe, the Islamists are deeply entrenched and can increasingly wield Muslim communities as a weapon of political domination against their host states.
It is already happening and will continue to happen. In order to ensure it keeps happening, the Islamists will want to import more and more Muslims, faster and faster, into European lands.
This is extremely similar to what happened in Ulster. Most Catholics in Ulster have never been members of the IRA, but the IRA (and its various factions) have wielded extraordinary political power via (at most) a few thousand committed cadres.
The only solution is to root out Islamism from Muslim communities, but it is already too late to do this.
This is the very definition of a slow-moving train wreck.
10, 20 years from now people will ask “how could we not have seen this coming” and the truth will be that we could, but our leaders found it expedient to ignore it all and hope for the best.
Nobody successfully assimilates Muslims. They just keep the numbers down.
France didn't "lose" the ability to assimilate Muslims. That ability simply never existed --because Muslims are the committed enemy of the West.
They didn't come to France to contribute. They came to France to kill, loot, and take control. This was always the plan and it was always obvious. Only a leftist could overlook such a fundamental truth.
Whether this is true on a larger scale is demonstrated by statistical data and I don’t see the evidence, and whether it’s true on the individual level is contradicted by examples such as the ones I offered in the article. The threat is real, I agree, and the ideology is as you say, but most people have multiple interests and are defined by various formative influences.
They are the worst people in the world. The are the enemy of Europe, and you'd better realize that before too late.
They are coming to kill you. Literally, not figuratively.
Thank you for a great article cheers
If France were a person, it would be someone with a severe narcissistic disorder—constantly lecturing others while ignoring its own faults and shortcomings, and hypocritically disregarding its own procalimed ideals whenever it suits the situation.
These protests—or rather, riots, however the media might choose to spin the narrative—are downplayed in Europe as merely part of "French culture." While that may be true to some extent, it seems that with each passing year, the French become increasingly blinded by this myth of theirs; as long as they can enjoy a glass of wine and a cigarette on a café terrace, they simply do not care.
France is burning and the Western press acts like it’s a damn optical illusion. Streets on fire, social order cracking, but the media tiptoes around it, terrified of admitting their own failures. Yet when Iran sneezes, they scream apocalypse for weeks. That’s the filthy hypocrisy: silence when chaos erupts at home, hysteria when it’s abroad. Their narrative machine is exposed — selective outrage, selective truth, selective morality — all of it rotten, all of it collapsing.
Fantastic piece , and I do have to wonder if you reach a place where assimilation is no longer realistically an option. The question is , where do you find the "grownups" who are willing and able to confront this? This appears to be far beyond "a house divided".
I grew up in the banlieues in the '70s, I've been living in the US for close to 30 years.
What I would have liked to see in this summary:
-the rise of Islamism dates from the '80s (probably started in the late '70s after the oil shocks and the Iranian revolution), with the Gulf funding madrassas, mosques etc. in France then.
-most Arabs in France (people did not call them Muslims then) were pretty secular when I grew up, up until maybe the '90s. There were exceptions of course.
-Islamic radicalism attracts mostly 2nd, 3rd and 4th generation North-Africans (and others from Muslim background) in search of identity: they resent their parents and grandparents for being sell-outs.
-I have no doubt recent immigration waves brought their share of potential Islamists, but the native born are the brunt of it (see Bataclan).
-During the Algerian war the FLN motto was "La valise ou le cercueil" (the suitcase or the coffin), their strategy was a precursor to the Second Intifada: terrorise the civilian population, especially the youth, and they will leave. Hamas fully embraced the FLN strategy. Mujahideen was a term used for Arab fighters during the war.
-the Algerian civil war spilled in France in the '90s, fueling the then FN (Front National) and igniting the identification of young Arabs with the Muslim Brotherhood.
The current riots are more cosplay than real I would think, in spite of the violence, since '68 the French regularly love to ape the French Revolution and reach another year zero.
That being said, there is a large Muslim population now in France, and you'll see that a lot more poignantly in small towns, that does not and cannot integrate French society with its liberal values: equality of the sexes, tolerance of homosexuality and other religions etc.
This will pave the way for the Rassemblement National of LePen.
How do you feel about the 2027 elections? If you had to vote today, which party/politician would you support ?
No idea, certainly not LFI, nor RF. Macron is done I would think.
Always puzzled when visiting France. The people who created such beauty, then let people trounce all over it.
A thought - how come citizens with origins from Haiti and Vietnam (both former colonies, with the first one having had to pay for its freedom over centuries, leaving it in heavy debt) seem to not be doing this? When Muslims were trying to take over public spaces for prayer, there were a lot of black people in the crowd who protested for secularism.
The problem in France right now is mainly Islam, but it's not just Islam. It's having a critical mass of Muslims, the erosion of assimilative institutions for immigrants, a collaborationist left, and a complicit media ecosystem.
Sadly this problem is also in the UK, as much as the mainstream insists on denying it and even Conservative politicians try to excuse Sharia courts here.
Remarkable that France has been laid to ruin with not a peep from leadership.
This is an excellent summary. I live in France and I can tell you that the situation is difficult and polarized. There is the far left which is Islamist -leftist and the far right which anti-european and frankly very scary. We have the perfect horseshoe where both extremes have a similar economic disastrous policy and pro-Russian and anti-Semitic stance. We would need a de Gaulle to bring order to this mess. The next year’s elections will be critical.
France hasn’t forgotten itself.
It is simply rerunning the French Revolution add infinitum.
This time around, the useful idiots are Islamo-communists.
Same shit, different colors.
The Second Battle of Tours